Metal Air Batteries

When you drive your car, you are combusting the hydrocarbons in your gas tank with oxygen in the outside air to produce CO2 and H2O. If you had to carry the oxygen around with you instead of getting it free from the outside air, your car would have to be much, much bigger.  In fact, to combust the 20 gallons of gas in your gas tank requires the oxygen in more than 1.5 tons of air, as much air as fills (uncompressed) roughly 10 suburban houses. 

The potential advantage for Metal-Air batteries is similar to that for gasoline in that you have to store only one reactant.  The other reactant, Oxygen, you get for free from the air around.  In the case of Zinc-Air, however, no net gasses are produced as the battery stores and then releases Oxygen during the charge/discharge cycle. 

Actually, almost everyone has seen and used Metal-Air batteries.  As they are a common battery chemistry for use as button cells.

 

A rechargeable metal-air battery cell might be of flow battery design or not. A typical metal-air reaction involves a cell with an air-cathode, an electrode where Oxygen is available on one side, and the electrolyte (an aqueous Potassium Hydroxide solution is typical) is on the other.  The Oxygen reacts at the air cathode with the electrolyte to form Hydroxides (OH- ions), which may then react with the ionic metal to form, for example, elemental Zinc.   The drawing here is just one of many potential metal-air designs, using an organic acid as electrolyte and an ionic membrane.  

The reactant metal, Zinc for example, is plated or accumulates on an electrode in a Zinc-Air cell during the charging phase, and is turned back into Zinc ions in solution during the discharge phase. 

Metal Air cells have at least the potential of virtually unlimited cyclability.  In addition, metal air cells may have a high energy density, and, for Zinc-Air cells, may be constructed of relatively benign, inexpensive materials, and could potentially be the safest of large scale batteries.  The main detriment to Metal Air batteries is a somewhat lower efficiency, and the issue of loss of water through the air cathode.

Several companies are in development on utility-scale metal-air batteries, but no company presently is manufacturing metal-air batteries on a utility scale. 

Unlimited cyclability, good energy density and inexpensive, relatively safe materials?  Why don't we have these today?  Several issues, but primarily the problems of making an effective air cathode. In 1993 Sandia National Laboratories performed a very comprehensive study on Zinc Air batteries.  This study was focused primarily on the use of Zinc Air batteries in electric vehicles, and many of the issues were specific to this application.  However, the main outstanding issue was the air cathode.. how to create an air cathode that would efficiently catalyze the hydroxide reaction and not corrode or degrade over time.

An important note is that IBM announced in August of 2009 a major effort to develop a Lithium-Air battery, which has the potential of producing 'serious' electric vehicle batteries, batteries with an energy density sufficient to power a car for 400 miles.  Because of the high reactivity of Lithium metal, IBM will have to create an air membrane that passes Oxygen freely while denying even a trace of water vapor.  While it is unlikely that this will produce a cost effective utility scale battery, it is an effort worth following. 

In addition, several companies are working on Zinc-Air batteries where the Zinc anodes, once oxidized, are mechanically removed and replaced, and then reprocessed at some remote factory.

However, the biggest new potential technology in Metal-Air batteries is being funded by the DOE to Arizona State spin off Fluidic Energy. Called Metal-Air Ionic Liquid or MAIL batteries, the advance here is the potential use of Ionic Liquids as electrolyte. Imagine transparent shampoo, a viscous liquid that doesn't evaporate, and conducts electricity well.  Because Ionic liquids won't evaporate, the air cathode or air membrane that is required in a Metal-Air battery won't dry out over time, reducing capacity.  In addition, the use of Ionic liquids may allow different types of air cathodes to be used. 

Another major benefit of MAIL batteries is that the Ionic Liquid electrolyte won't electrolysize into Hydrogen and Oxygen.  In any battery using aqueous electrolytes, the materials used are limited by the fact that an electrode voltage in excess of 1.23 volts will begin to electrolysize Hydrogen out of the water.  Higher-energy metals than, say, Zinc can't be used because of this issue.  By using an electrolyte of Ionic Liquids, it may be possible to use a these higher-energy metals, and therefore build a battery of much higher energy density, potentially an order of magnitude higher than Lithium Ion.  
 

Metal Air Batteries could be the eventual big winner in utility scale energy storage.  The challenge:  Build a better air cathode/membrane.